Skip to content

Bitos

Welcome to Bitos

Bankruptcy: Understanding the Consequences and How to Get Back on Your Feet Financially

Bankruptcy fraud is a criminal offence, not a synonym for insolvency. Under French law, it refers to fraudulent management practices committed by a…

Homme d'affaires en détresse face à des documents financiers évoquant une situation de banqueroute
5 min

Bankruptcy fraud is a criminal offense, not a synonym for insolvency. Under French law, it refers to fraudulent management practices committed by a company director, provided that reorganization or liquidation proceedings have first been opened.

Article L. 654-2 of the French Commercial Code lists the conduct covered: misappropriation of assets, fraudulently increasing liabilities, keeping fictitious accounts, or failing to maintain proper accounting records. A company can therefore be liquidated without its director being prosecuted for bankruptcy fraud, as long as none of these acts is established.

Personal liability of a company director after judicial liquidation

The most common misconception is that judicial liquidation automatically makes the director personally liable for the company’s debts. This is not the case. The company, as a legal entity, is responsible for its own debts.

Liquidation does not automatically create personal debt for the director. Their personal assets remain protected unless the court finds a specific management error that contributed to the shortfall in assets. This action for liability for insufficiency of assets is separate from bankruptcy fraud: it falls under commercial law, not criminal law.

Several situations can expose a director to personal liability. The website banqueroute.be explains how personal assets may be affected following insolvency proceedings. The most common cases include personal guarantees signed with banks, unpaid shareholder current accounts, and judgments for management errors.

  • A personal guarantee makes the director liable with their own assets, regardless of what happens to the company. Even after the liquidation is closed, the secured creditor can pursue the guarantor.
  • An action for liability for insufficiency of assets requires proof of a management error that contributed to the liabilities. Commercial failure alone is not enough to trigger it.
  • If commingling of assets is established, the court may extend the insolvency proceedings to the director personally, but this remains an exceptional situation.

Woman holding official documents outside a courthouse in connection with bankruptcy proceedings

Bankruptcy fraud and criminal offenses: what the Commercial Code penalizes

Bankruptcy fraud is not a catch-all offense. The Commercial Code defines specific forms of conduct, and each must be proven for a criminal conviction. Insolvency alone does not constitute bankruptcy fraud.

The offenses fall into several categories. Misappropriating or concealing assets—for example, emptying the company’s accounts before declaring insolvency—is the most commonly prosecuted offense. Fraudulently increasing liabilities, such as taking on fictitious debts to engineer insolvency, is also covered.

Accounting irregularities and bankruptcy fraud

Failing to keep accounts in accordance with legal requirements, or keeping fictitious or incomplete accounts, are among the grounds for bankruptcy fraud. A director who has failed to produce financial statements for several financial years may face prosecution once insolvency proceedings are opened.

Penalties include imprisonment and fines, as well as additional sanctions such as a ban on managing a company and the loss of civil rights. The criminal court may be petitioned by the public prosecutor, the court-appointed insolvency practitioner, or the liquidator.

Preventive measures before insolvency proceedings

Most directors learn about preventive procedures too late. Two options make it possible to negotiate with creditors before liquidation becomes the only option.

An ad hoc mandate is available as long as the company is not insolvent. The director asks the president of the court to appoint a representative to facilitate negotiations with creditors. The procedure is confidential, helping to avoid panic among business partners.

Conciliation is available within a narrower window: it can be requested if the company has been insolvent for less than 45 days. The conciliator has a few months to reach an amicable agreement. If the court approves the agreement, it is binding on the creditors who signed it.

Neither of these options is a recovery procedure after liquidation. Their value lies in prevention: a director who anticipates cash flow problems has more room to maneuver than one who waits until insolvency is confirmed.

Couple meeting with a financial advisor to find solutions after bankruptcy

Starting over after liquidation: distinguishing business failure from fraud

A director whose company has been liquidated is not barred from setting up another business unless they have been convicted of a criminal offense that includes a ban on managing a company. Business failure is not a criminal offense.

The distinction between liquidation and bankruptcy fraud determines what happens next. A director with no conviction can register a new company as soon as the liquidation is closed. In practice, the main obstacles are usually banking-related: securing financing after a liquidation remains difficult because lenders check the director’s history.

Preparing a new venture after liquidation

Three precautions can help avoid obstacles. First, make sure the liquidation has officially been closed and that no ban on managing a company has been entered on the criminal record. Next, settle or renegotiate any personal guarantees that are still in force, as they may affect the director’s ability to borrow for a new venture.

Finally, the legal structure of the new venture deserves careful consideration. Separating personal and business assets from the outset (by choosing a limited liability company structure and avoiding personal guarantees) reduces the risk that a second failure will affect the director’s personal assets.

French law does not penalize entrepreneurial risk-taking in itself. Bankruptcy fraud punishes fraud, not failure. A director who kept proper accounts, declared insolvency on time, and cooperated with the parties involved in the insolvency proceedings can still pursue a new venture, even if the previous one ended in liquidation.

Bankruptcy: Understanding the Consequences and How to Get Back on Your Feet Financially